Don't Talk to the Police
Regent University School of Law13 HN recommenders · recommended in 12 months, 2017–2026
lecture · general · evergreen · 2017–2026 on HN
Regent Law professor James Duane gives startling reasons why people, even innocent ones, should always exercise their Fifth Amendment rights rather than talk to police. It is based on his article and book on the subject.
HN treats it as the canonical video to link whenever talking to police or interrogations come up.
Up next
4 mo on HNMilton Friedman - The Real World Effects Of Unions
LibertyPen
4 HN recommender · 2017–2023
15 mo on HNBut what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction.
3Blue1Brown
16 HN recommender · 2018–2025
1 mo on HNWhy Can't we Remake the Rocketdyne F1 Engine?
Curious Droid
1 HN recommend · 2019–2022
3 mo on HNBruce Hauman - Developing ClojureScript With Figwheel
ClojureTV
3 HN recommender · 2017–2022
11 mo on HNLight Years Ahead | The 1969 Apollo Guidance Computer
TNMoC
11 HN recommender · 2021–2026
10 mo on HNYouTube's copyright system isn't broken. The world's is.
Tom Scott
13 HN recommender · 2020–2024
11 mo on HNAntonin Scalia - On American Exceptionalism
AmericanRhetoric.com
12 HN recommender · 2019–2025
10 mo on HNThe Cardboard Box Reform - Nixon's Ghost Bill & A Crucial Flaw in Democracy
CRI
9 HN recommender · 2014–2025
8 mo on HNSeattle is Dying | A KOMO News Documentary
KOMO News
10 HN recommender · 2019–2024
7 mo on HNEverything is a Remix (Original Series)
Kirby Ferguson
7 HN recommender · 2017–2026
7 mo on HNThe Machinery Of Freedom: Illustrated summary
bitbutter
4 HN recommender · 2012–2020
6 mo on HNCybersecurity as Realpolitik by Dan Geer presented at Black Hat USA 2014
Black Hat
1 HN recommend · 2014–2023
12 comments from Hacker News
No, not really. Advice for police interrogation is: never talk to the police. If you don't know why, you must watch this: ▶ this video Also, I never said this is my advice. In general I like to volunteer information during interview when I am the candidate. I think it lets me control the situation a little bit better and move to ground that I have much more expertise in. I am just saying that I can't fault candidate for not doing this.
> If you do want to talk to me, I can tell the juvenile court judge or adult court judge and Probation Officer what you tell me. It's missing the explicit warning that "what you say can and will be used against you in the court of law." I think they should add a clause to the end stating "and they can use this information against you to get you in trouble." This video is always relevant when the subject of talking to police comes up: ▶ this video
If they wanted to do that, your chances of "I talk, and it screws me" are pretty high anyway. Also, don't take my word for it - here's a US police officer saying the same thing: ▶ this video (skip to the second half) He wouldn't talk to police.
Indeed. As to why, see this video with Regent Law Professor James Duane: ▶ this video It's pretty shocking.
> They can use "I don't remember" ? They absolutely can, and will use that in a court of law. Any comment that you make that seems completely fine from your perspective can quickly be turned around to lock you up. I highly recommend checking out this lecture when you get a chance: ▶ this video Police are not generally concerned with getting the right person, they're just concerned with getting a person.
> Don't talk to the police: Regent Law Professor James Duane gives viewers startling reasons why they should always exercise their 5th Amendment rights when questioned by government officials. ▶ this video
This is terrible advice. Do not talk to the police. You have nothing to gain and everything to lose. Contact a lawyer. ▶ this video
In case people are not aware yet, please watch this video about "Don't talk to the police". ▶ this video
You might find this interesting, where a lawyer explains why should never say a single word to the police, under any circumstances: ▶ this video
> The "don't talk to police" mantra is for when you know that you've done something wrong Not true. Rewatch the original video. It covers exactly this. ▶ this video
> I've been part of the group who got asked to give a DNA sample in the Nicky Verstappen [1] case. This was voluntarily, and I reluctantly did this Great story and thanks for sharing this. I want to answer why I think this is a bad idea however. First, I would talk to a legal defense attorney before doing this. A famous video about this topic is here ▶ this video . 1) The police might have told you it was for one case but it was for another, as the police can lie. 2) The DNA test itself might give a false positive on you or your family members, putting your family to a harsher scrutiny by the police that would have otherwise, and with more judicial justification. In the investigatory zeal they might find other lesser crimes they might want to prosecute just to not be empty handed. In the U.S., they might have charged a family member on a false positive with a ridiculously overblown crime. People have killed themselves over that prosecutorial technique ( link ) 3) The police could fiddle with the samples and plant evidence if they thought you or someone else did it. (Steven Avery case) 4) The lab might fake results if they are in tandem with the DA ( link ) You are gambling with your life and the life of your family members when you make that choice. And if you were so sure a family member of yours did not do it, then the police could have come to the same conclusion on their alibis and physical state of your family members. Even if you believe non of that is "likely to happen"
The video titled 'don´t talk to the police' ▶ this video is a very serious message from a lawyer and a cop not to say a single word since it will be used against you. The same is true for Musk and twitter.