HackerTube

Don't Talk to the Police

Regent University School of Law13 HN recommenders · recommended in 12 months, 2017–2026
YouTube
lecture · general · evergreen · 2017–2026 on HN

Regent Law professor James Duane gives startling reasons why people, even innocent ones, should always exercise their Fifth Amendment rights rather than talk to police. It is based on his article and book on the subject.

HN treats it as the canonical video to link whenever talking to police or interrogations come up.

12 comments from Hacker News

@lmilcin2021-06 · in “Tips for Interviewing over Zoom”

No, not really. Advice for police interrogation is: never talk to the police. If you don't know why, you must watch this: ▶ this video Also, I never said this is my advice. In general I like to volunteer information during interview when I am the candidate. I think it lets me control the situation a little bit better and move to ground that I have much more expertise in. I am just saying that I can't fault candidate for not doing this.

Strongly recommends View on HN
@Chaebixi2017-09 · in “King County rolls out Miranda rights tailored for young people”

> If you do want to talk to me, I can tell the juvenile court judge or adult court judge and Probation Officer what you tell me. It's missing the explicit warning that "what you say can and will be used against you in the court of law." I think they should add a clause to the end stating "and they can use this information against you to get you in trouble." This video is always relevant when the subject of talking to police comes up: ▶ this video

Strongly recommends View on HN
@digitalPhonix2026-06 · in “Never talk to the police”

If they wanted to do that, your chances of "I talk, and it screws me" are pretty high anyway. Also, don't take my word for it - here's a US police officer saying the same thing: ▶ this video (skip to the second half) He wouldn't talk to police.

Recommends View on HN
@lclc2025-11 · in “Stopping bad guys from using my open source project (feedback wanted)”

Indeed. As to why, see this video with Regent Law Professor James Duane: ▶ this video It's pretty shocking.

Recommends View on HN
@throwaway19091p2024-02 · in “WA House bill would make it illegal for police to lie during interrogations”

> They can use "I don't remember" ? They absolutely can, and will use that in a court of law. Any comment that you make that seems completely fine from your perspective can quickly be turned around to lock you up. I highly recommend checking out this lecture when you get a chance: ▶ this video Police are not generally concerned with getting the right person, they're just concerned with getting a person.

Recommends View on HN