HackerTube

Bryan Mills jumps a fence

MartialArtsFightsCited 3× on HN, 2020–2024
YouTube
other · general · evergreen · 2020–2024 on HN

A very short clip from Taken 3 of Liam Neeson's character jumping a fence, edited with extremely rapid cuts.

Used as a stock example of overly fast cutting and shaky-cam action filmmaking.

3 comments from Hacker News

@jsheard2024-04 · in “VideoGigaGAN: Towards detail-rich video super-resolution”

:( "Our model encounters challenges when processing >200 frame videos" :) "Our model is proven production-ready using real-world footage from Taken 3" ▶ this video

@ryandrake2023-05 · in “Alien was released 44 years ago today”

Your comment reminds me of the classic example: Taken 3 where they used 15 cuts in 6 seconds[1] to show Liam Neeson jumping over a fence. You can barely hold people's attention for 400 milliseconds. 1: ▶ this video

@nostromo2020-11 · in “David Fincher’s Impossible Eye”

> The camera moved at the same speed as Affleck, gliding with unvarying smoothness, which is exactly how Fincher likes his shots to behave. I appreciate this so much. There’s a lot of shaky cam out there and it often gives me motion sickness or confuses my understanding of the scene. It also feels like a cheap trick directors use to create faux excitement, or to cover up sloppy filmmaking. Fincher movies are easy to watch and understand visually. He does a lot of wide shots and long shots without sloppy cuts. In Panic Room he did a single shot (although CGI) that lasted several minutes and showed the viewer around the entire set in a single uninterrupted view. It was glorious. I wish this approach was more common. Although I expect it’s not because it’s hard to accomplish. Here are two of the worst abuses of fast cut, shaky cam scenes out there: ▶ this video link

Critical View on HN