DAIRY IS SCARY!
Erin Janus3 HN recommenders · recommended in 5 months, 2019–2023
commentary · general · evergreen · 2019–2023 on HN
Vegan advocate Erin Janus explains the dairy industry in about five minutes, covering how milk is produced and the treatment of cows and calves. It is an advocacy piece and includes graphic material.
HN commenters in veganism and food threads link it as a short, info-dense explanation that some say opened their eyes, though others dispute it.
Up next
8 mo on HNLife in Syntropy
Agenda Gotsch
4 HN recommender · 2017–2023
9 mo on HNDr. Michael Greger | How Not To Die | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
8 HN recommender · 2016–2022
5 mo on HNCollapse of Complex Societies by Dr. Joseph Tainter
vlada888
5 HN recommender · 2015–2023
6 mo on HNToward Rational, Authentic Food Choices | Melanie Joy | TEDxMünchen
TEDx Talks
3 HN recommender · 2015–2023
2 mo on HNArithmetic, Population and Energy - FULL LENGTH
kip399
3 HN recommender · 2016–2024
4 mo on HNHow to Enjoy the End of the World
Sid Smith
4 HN recommender · 2019–2026
2 mo on HN#Earth 🌏 Will we survive this ? Amazing⚡️ #crashcourse on #collapse & #environment by #ArthurKeller
NEXT - Les Mondes Sensibles (byThePassengerStudio)
2 HN recommender · 2020–2023
12 mo on HNDominion (2018) - full documentary [Official]
Farm Transparency Project
10 HN recommender · 2019–2024
11 mo on HNTreating the Farm as an Ecosystem with Gabe Brown Part 1, The 5 Tenets of Soil Health
Living Web Farms
12 HN recommender · 2019–2025
10 mo on HNThe Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8)
wonderingmind42
13 HN recommender · 2010–2025
9 mo on HNHow to green the world's deserts and reverse climate change | Allan Savory
TED
9 HN recommender · 2013–2023
8 mo on HNEating less Meat won't save the Planet. Here's Why
Joseph Everett - WIL
10 HN recommender · 2021–2026
12 comments from Hacker News
Here's a 5 minute video that would explain why the newer generations are so mad about the unethical practices of Dairy industry. I know it opened my eyes: ▶ this video
> and is unhealthy and worse than full cream milk Dairy is scary: ▶ this video Derived from a bovine's udder, cow milk is essentially a white, viscous secretion containing fats, hormones, bioaccumulated pesticides and herbicides, and sometimes pus and blood from infected teats, all filtered through a mammary gland that often comes into contact with dirt and feces during the extraction process. Cow milk, routinely touted as a wholesome beverage, can legally contain up to 400 million somatic cells (often referred to as pus) per milliliter in the U.S., and traces of blood, all originating from inflamed and possibly infected bovine udders, making one wonder about the purity of the seemingly innocent white liquid. Cow's milk also naturally contains hormones, including Insulin-like Growth Factor-1, estrogens, progesterone, prolactin, and oxytocin; also some cows receive artificial hormones like rBST to enhance production; when consumed regularly, those hormones may impact the growth and reproductive functions of consumers. In the relentless cycle of dairy production, cows endure forced impregnation and a shortened lifespan — typically 5 years instead of the potential 25+. The record lifespan for a cow is 48 years. Newborn males are typically culled immediately, while females are separated from their mothers shortly after birth, crying for each other usually for weeks. And we haven't addressed the land needs and environmental impact of dairy production. This includes deforestation for pa
> India ... has one of the lowest consumptions of animal protein and yet low life expectancy False cause fallacy. > You don't have to eat a lot, but you have to eat some Because you say so? Or do you have a source for your claims? > Breast milk is animal protein, or you'd have to include dairy too Vegans have a saying: "not your mother, not your milk". It's one fallacy after another. You really should read the article I've linked, it's all there. Read it. At least skim it. It's not that hard. > You can justify it for animal cruelty reasons, but not for health reasons You think that adult humans have to drink cow milk to be healthy, do I understand you correctly? Not dog milk, not lion, giraffe, rat, pig milk, but cow milk specifically? You don't read, so let's try youtube. ▶ this video Dairy is scary link Milk: The White Lie We've All Been Sold link How big government helps big dairy sell milk
> I was actually raised vegetarian and generally prefer vegetarian dishes. If you've been raised vegetarian, it's possible you have some blind spots. A lot of people have an idealized picture of how the industry works. Have you seen "dairy is scary" ? ▶ this video Or dominion? link > know that many things that are sold to us as greener, arent Certainly, that's why I would recommend focusing on science rather than mass or social media.
Understand your points of view. I too ate meat for a long time. I too defended that position with same ferocity you do. But I was wrong to do it. And you're wrong on too many points to discuss it at full - sorry, no space here, also have family to feed and work to do. My bookmarks folder about dangers of animal products/agriculture has hundreds of items. I'll cherrypick just few of them to get you started. You'll find several of your viewpoints discussed here: link Want to learn more? (pun intended) Movies: - I'd recommend Dominion movie again, but you won't probably see it, and even if you do, i don't think the suffering of animals/horrors of the meat production will be enough to change your opinions, so I'll talk about it from different angle. - Cowspiracy - Seaspiracy link - This man makes you think ▶ this video - Dairy is scary Health: link - Dr. Michael Greger | How Not To Die link - Foods for Protecting the Body & Mind: Dr. Neal Barnard link - What the Health! (2017) Impacts on biodiversity / climate change: link link link link OK, I'll react to few of your points. > "never personally eat meat strikes me as a bit of a neurotic, narcissistic response" So avoiding killing is a neurotic, narcissistic response? Like, really? > "to avoid ice cream to spare dairy cows who are clearly, if you meet them, quite happy with their jobs" Are you sure? I've met a lot of them, when i was a child. You know that cows giving milk are mothers, forcefully impregnated/raped eve
Cows only make milk after pregnancy. That has to happen somehow. Guess what is done with her baby. Guess where the literal pus from the overworked udders ends up. Yum! All those vegetarians sure are enjoying that. If you want to know more fun facts, check out Dairy is scary on YouTube - ▶ this video
> (decaf) latte I'm running on regular coffee, no milk. > Oh wait I forgot about cheese Try link - 1800+ plant based cheeses, perhaps one or two would satisfy your taste buds? :) > life without milk is udderly untenable I've missed yoghurt the most. Fortunately coconut milk based yoghurts are quite palatable. Sorry, I have to. Did you know that dairy is scary? ▶ this video
Vegans have cheese. Salty and fatty, melts. You should try it. There is no magic ingredient in cow (dog, giraffe, lion, bat, dolphin) milk that we couldn't get from plants instead. ▶ this video link (1700+ cheeses from all over the world)
> To call other things "cheese" that aren't cheese is torturing the very definition of the word, much like "milk" Yes, if it doesn't have torture, blood, puss, pesticides, antibiotics and estrogens in it, it can't be called milk or cheese. Why torture? How else would you call forced impregnation, year after year, and forced separation of mothers and calves? Just to shorten the cow's life from 25+ years to 5 and then turn her to burgers. ▶ this video > has been traditionally understood, inconveniently for you, as excretion from mammary glands Inconveniently for you, soybean, almond, coconut, rice, oat, hemp, even poppy milk was used for centuries, millenia even, all over the world. > and my eyes alighted on "gypsum" link So you probably don't drink beer, eat baked goods or farmed mushrooms too. Got it. Btw, there are other coagulants, like nigari, epsom salt, calcium chloride, lemon juice or vinegar ... Not everybody is scared of 1 tbsp of gypsum in several kg of tofu, so that's why they probably use it. In my view it's much better than contents of someone's stomach. But I'm me. I wonder what other poisonous chemicals were there. Do you have the list? :) Btw, do you know, that there's l-cystein in most flours on the market, and that's often made from human hair? link Our food industry is so ingenious.
You'd still get pus, blood, endotoxins, hormones (like estrogen), pesticides/herbicides (organic farms still usually use them), etc. Only 40% of consumers in UK [0] know that a cow has to give a birth to a calf to be able to give milk. Male calves are usually immediately killed these days, or sold for meat in a few months (together with 25?% of female calves). In dairy industry calves are removed from their mothers the day they're born (only 27% of consumers know this), in beef industry they're usually kept together. The saddest story I've seen is a mother cow who gave birth to two calves. Because she was not first-time mother, she prepared. One calf was immediately taken away, the other she managed to hide somewhere in the fields. Of course when the farmer found about it (insufficient milk output), he located the calf and took it away. I can't find it, but here is a similar story. [1] All dairy cows are forcibly impregnated every year, are spent after 5-6 years to the point where they often can no more walk [2], and instead of a normal life which would be 20-48? years (upper number is the record) they're taken to the slaughterhouse [3]. > humane conditions for the cows That doesn't exist, not even on small local farms. Humane? It's an oxymoron. [0] link [1] link [2] ▶ this video - Dairy is scary! [3] link
90+% (IIRC) of slaughtered animals in US are from CAFOs. Any kind of slaughter is inhumane when there's no NEED to eat meat. The clean process you may have seen in TV is different from reality (see recent CO2 chambers relevations [0]). Taking away mother's young and taking milk mother produces for her (him is killed usually immediatelly) is inhumane. [1] Etc. I've seen Dr Temple Grandin's "Glass Walls" ... she is not the right person for the job of representing "humane animal treatment." Yes, she says what you want to hear. But not the right person for the animals. [0] link [1] ▶ this video
> To industrialized abuse ... I don't know, 95+% ? > That you don't see a problem to solve ... You can solve it by not participating. > Go look at the Wikipedia page for the film ... The film is (mostly) compilation of the responses of health professionals, some passages are debatable, and i'm not ready to defend the work. I haven't linked any scientific sources, because those are biased as well - you can always find sources from both camps. I've linked this film because it's easy to digest and covers some of the areas where you're so off. But you haven't looked (i'm pretty sure) at any link i've provided previously. > The explanation that was given to me for this practice was to protect the calfs, which makes sense to me ... Beef calves are kept with their mothers. Where there is a profit motive (milk), calves are taken away. Where there isn't, calves are kept with their mothers. Hmm. Maybe just milk cows are horrible mothers? > That's part of their job! Job? You're surely joking. > Animals. Aren't. People! They don't talk (as we do). They don't think as we do. But they have intelligence, and are capable of suffering. Isn't it enough? > ... also nowhere close to true. Producing milk does not leave the cow exhausted and crippled ... Absent farming needs, cows have a typical lifespan of 15 to 20 years. That lifespan could even understate their longevity. Guinness World Records lists the oldest cow as 48 years and nine months old. link > Producing milk does not leave the cow